Thursday, October 25, 2012


Post-reading for week 8
     Some reasons that some students may be “misdiagnosed” with learning disability may be because of race or even gender and some factors are class and language. A person of color might be tested with a language he/she is not familiar with and as a result, they fail the test because they have no clue on what they are being tested on. A typical example is when a Hispanic person is tested in English to know if the person has a Learning disorder; the person is highly likely to fail this test because he/she does not speak English. And with class, according to one of the articles we read, the whites have more money to pay for special tests for their children and that is how they come up with names like “dyslexia” just so their kids are not referred to as Learning Disabled kids.
     There is a standard that has already been set and if you do not fit into all these you are not fully normal like they insinuate. With normalcy, you have to be White, middle class, and able bodied. In school settings, when the teachers see that a student is not up to these standard or is somewhat different from what they theme “normal” they label the student Learning Disabled. It could also be if a student is not grasping knowledge as quickly as the teacher wants or the student is not of best conduct in school like the teacher would want them to be and the teachers can no longer deal with that, they label those kind of students “learning Disabled”, “Mentally Retarded”, or “Emotionally disturbed”.
     When it comes to race, minorities are always the target. They are always underrated and put aside; the teachers often think minorities do not value education (just like in color blind racism) and so any little mistake they make makes them disabled. In the case of class, when a student is not middle class, there is a huge possibility that they would be taken for granted and when they don’t perform well in class, the teacher might say it is as a result of them being “Emotionally disturbed” and so they are thinking of their financial condition.  Lastly, gender plays a huge role too because teachers feel male students are more disable. I think this is because the males are more active in most cases and so a way for the teachers not to deal with too much drama from the male, they put them in Special Ed classes.
    I think race as a social construct and disability as a social construct are similar when it comes to how they were formed. They were formed by people and there is hardly any biological relation to prove some of their conclusions. They are things that people come up with just to discriminate or segregate people in the society. I think they are different when it comes to who is involved. Race has to do with minorities mostly while with disability, there is a lot of intersectionality that can go on (race, class, sexuality e.t.c).
     Problems that “in-child” view may cause are inequality and biasness. Some teachers believe that a certain group of people or certain races do not do well in school, like I said before “minorities” and so even before the student is tested, it is assumed that this “learning disability” runs in the student’s ancestry therefore the student is no way different from his/her ancestors. This kind of framework hides racism because it has to do with race. (Color-blind racism is practiced).
Race, class, and language intersect when we are talking about disability. When we compare a person of color that is not middle class and is disabled, to a white person that is not middle class but disabled, we see that the white still gets preferential treatment no matter what. But using intersectionality makes us understand that the fact that someone is white does not mean they cannot be disabled.
     One thing that definitely surprised me was from one of the articles we read that talked about how teachers assume that a student has a learning disability because they (teachers) think it is in the student’s ancestry line. That is ridiculous; people have different ways of assimilating and so their abilities should not be compared to that of their kind or even their family.
Word count: 730

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home