Post-reading response for week 7
Indeed, domestic violence cuts across all races, ethnicities, sexualities and cultures.
Intersectional analysis uses these categories to understand that an individual does
not experience domestic violence because he/she is from any of these categories
such as race, ethnicity and so long. It shows how these things intersect with
each other in our society and how people going through domestic violence have
these intersectional qualities. The example that challenges the traditional
narrative of Domestic Violence that surprised me the most is the Kibra article.
Where in the Vietnamese community DV is culturally acceptable and they solve
the problem by talking about it within themselves. They actually believe that
involving the community helps to end DV and they do not recommend the woman
going through DV to leave her marriage. I think it is a way of ensuring that in
the Vietnamese community there are few broken homes. Another thing that
surprised me is in the Serwer article, where Native Americans cannot be helped
out of DV once they are married to an Anglo man. They say they cannot persecute
an Anglo man, so a Native American woman that is stuck in a DV situation with
an Anglo man has to deal with it alone. I think we don’t hear about this anymore
because the traditional believe that is put up makes what is really happening
covert.
One huge barrier for people going through DV is the Language barrier and
this is in regards to immigrants that do not speak or understand English. This
is a huge barrier because the people going through Domestic violence find it
difficult to get help when they do not find someone that speaks the same
language with them. And the agencies cannot be of help either because they do
not understand what the person is saying. Another barrier is the fear that the
DV survivors have that their abuser would get them deported or would come after
them. An example is when they sneak out of the house just to get help from
their situation. The amount of time they spend outside the house is limited and
this is because they do not want to get in trouble with their abuser. The
abuser will be feeling suspicious and curious as to knowing what the DV
survivor is up to and would want to know where this DV survivor has been. The
abuser would threaten to report the survivor to the cops knowing that the
survivor would get deported and this survivor does not want that.
I learned about the U-Visa and how one doesn’t have
to be going through domestic violence or be of a particular race or ethnic
studies before one can apply for it. It is related to intersectional analysis
because it shows you how race and other factors intersect together. The U-Visa
helps to reduce criminals that have hurt people that can be persecuted. I learned
that an immigrant could be granted this visa as long as they are willing to
work with the police to help get the criminal arrested. Another thing I learnt
from Paola’s talk is that when children are involved, the DV case becomes more
complicated and could later result in the involvement of Child Services Department
who could take the kids away from them, and so from knowing this, most women
just bare the torture just so they do not lose their kids.
To better the DV services I would suggest a few more
things. It is very obvious that they have done a lot already and that is great,
but it would be even better if they increase the amount of shelters in
different areas; just like in the bay area (San Francisco to be precise) that has
its shelters full 80% of the time. And also they should create shelters for men
(both queer and straight) that are going through Domestic Violence since they
cannot be inhabited in the same shelters with DV surviving women for understandable
reasons. I would have said the covert fact that DV surviving men are not
allowed into DV shelters should be annulled but that is not putting the women
in those shelters into consideration. Another thing that should be done is the
increase in the amount of interpreters, so that victims of this act can always
have some to talk to that would understand what they are saying especially in
critical or emergency situations.
Using
an intersectional analysis does not help to end Domestic Violence because
understanding Domestic Violence does not stop the abusers from tormenting and
torturing their victims. It only helps us to understand that different aspects
of life intersect together when it comes to Domestic Violence and anyone could
go through Domestic Violence.
Word Count: 788

2 Comments:
Hi Abi,
Your explanation about DV and intersectionality is very articulate and thoughtful, well done! I agree with what you said at the end of your blog, using intersectionality may not solve DV by itself, however, I think that using an intersectional analysis is going to be key in making sure that we eradicate DV in a way that is encompassing of all populations. I am also glad to hear that you learned something from the lecture and from Paola- thanks for your engagement!
--eas
Hi Abi,
I was impressed by your understanding DV homes and your explanation of U-Visa. I too, was amazed how the U-Visa doesn't depend on just domestic violence within a relationship but it can be also by an unknown oppressor. For example, walking on the streets and someone mugged you or did something inappropriate, then you can be granted the U-Visa if your helped the police catch the suspect of the crime. Your blog is very thoughtful and it helped me further understand my knowledge about DV.
-Kriselle N.
Post a Comment
Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]
<< Home