Sunday, September 9, 2012


Post-Reading/Reflection Prompts for Week 1: History and Future of Ethnic Studies


The strike in 1968 by the SFSU students was based on the addition of ethnic studies to the school system. I don’t think there are many similarities between the issues facing students presently and the issues students faced in 1968. As flagrant as this may sound, there is still a little racism in SFSU. Though people would say racism is highly under control but that is totally not true, it still exists in a way.
The students of SFSU in 1968 struggled so hard during the strike for ethnic studies to come into existence because they believed that ethnic studies would enormously enlighten people about their heritage, culture, and everything about their ancestry. Mind you, their ulterior motive was to create unity and stop division and even oppression, like the essay by Helen Wilson wrote, “some white students began to express hostility to the growing use of students fund for black student education and activities” I think with this alone, the white were already making it obvious that they didn’t like the people of color. So the students of SFSU in 1968, wanted ethnic studies to help usurp these controversies.
If I were to imagine a conversation between one of the legislators of HB 2281 and a striker from the SFSU 1968 strike, all I would hear is cacophony. This is because these people stand at two ends and are fighting for opposite things. The state of Arizona banned the teaching of any ethnic related course in public schools because they feel it only teaches the kids to resent or hate other races. The legislator of HB 2218 will prove his point during the conversation by saying; ethnic studies promotes the overthrow of the united states government, promotes resentment towards a race or certain class of people, it is also designed only for people of a race and particular ethnic group, it advocates ethnic solidarity instead of treatment of students as individuals and therefore it should be banned. This would definitely not go well when an SFSU 1968 striker hears this because he (striker) is fighting for the creation of ethnic studies to overhaul racism, bring enlightenment about ancestral history and promote unity.
Mr. Horn is saying ethnic studies in schools divide the kids instead of uniting them, which is the sole aim of public schools. He says that having ethnic studies in schools makes a class often packed with a particular race. An example is having only African American students in a History of African American studies class etc. He supports his facts by saying that this is causing anger and hatred amongst students. On the other hand, Dyson states that ethnic studies is very important for everyone. It actually tells the stories that were left out of US history. He feels ethnic studies is here to remind us of the true history which includes the glory, hardships, and triumphs of the people of culture in America. He believes that even the white Americans can benefit from ethnic studies and that you don’t have to be a particular race for you to attend an ethnic studies class of that race. Sincerely, I think no knowledge is a waste and when a student takes an ethnic studies class that is different their own heritage, the student gets to know more about other cultures. It is different when you are being forced to take a course that you are not interested in taking and when you take a course because you value the knowledge that you would gain from it.
If I am asked why I am taking ethnic studies my response will be either I want to know more about my heritage, that is if I am taking a course related to my heritage but if otherwise, my reason will be because I want to know more about other cultures. Knowledge is power and therefore no knowledge is a waste.
Word count: 650

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home